Fish for a 100-Gallon Tank: 8 Freshwater Species and 3 That Outgrow It

10 min read

The short answer

Aqueon, an aquarium-products maker, puts 100 gallons in its 55-120 gallon band, which it says cichlids “generally dominate”: angelfish, firemouths and Malawi mbuna such as the yellow lab, alongside rainbowfish and Denison barbs. Discus fit by gallons, but Aqueon says they are “not for beginners”. Tinfoil barbs and, per Aquarium Co-Op, common plecos outgrow 100 gallons.

Aqueon’s 55-120 gallon list also names Convict and Texas cichlids, kribensis, the Tanganyikan brichardi, Julidochromis and shell dwellers, the giant danio as a “dither” fish, and the redtail shark (“you should only keep one adult per tank”). Aquarium Co-Op (Co-Op) and LiveAquaria (LA) are retailers. This guide is freshwater only. For smaller tanks, see our 55-gallon, 30-gallon and 20-gallon guides.

Size and Tank Size, Source by Source

LA says its angelfish figure is “TL (Total Length)”; the other sources do not say how they measure.

SpeciesAdult size, per sourceTank size, per source
Angelfish (Pterophyllum scalare)6 in (LA); body “up to 6 inches”, 8 in high with fins (Co-Op)55 gal “or larger when full grown” (Aqueon); 30 gal (LA); Co-Op: five or six juveniles in 55
Discus (Symphysodon)8 in (LA); “usually 5 to 7 inches in diameter” (Co-Op)75 gal or larger “when full grown” (Aqueon); 50 gal (LA); 75 gal or larger, 55 with “a lot of water changes” (Co-Op)
Firemouth cichlid (Thorichthys meeki)6 in (LA)30 gal (LA); named for 55-120 gal (Aqueon)
Yellow lab (Labidochromis caeruleus; Aqueon’s “Lemon Yellow Cichlid”)6 in (LA)“at least 55 gallons” for most Rift Lake cichlids (Aqueon); 50 gal (LA)
Boesemani rainbowfish (Melanotaenia boesemani)4 in (LA); males 4 in, females about 3 in (Co-Op)“at least 50 gallons” for most Melanotaeniids (Aqueon); 30 gal, 4 ft long for a school (LA); 4 ft long for adults (Co-Op)
Denison barb (Sahyadria denisonii)4.5 in (LA); “up to 5 inches” (Co-Op)55 gal “or larger when full size” (Aqueon); 50 gal (LA); a group “in a 4-foot tank (1.2 m) or longer” (Co-Op)
Clown loach (Chromobotia macracanthus)12 in (LA); 12-13 in “In our care” (Co-Op)100 gal (LA); Co-Op: 55 for juveniles “until they are about 3 years old or 6 inches (15 cm) long”, then “upgrade”
Oscar (Astronotus ocellatus)12 in (LA); “up to 14 inches” (Aqueon); 10-12 in “or more” (Co-Op)70 gal (LA); listed for 125 gal and up (Aqueon); Co-Op: 75 “is better” than 55 for one, “at least 90–100 gallons” for two

LA’s care levels: “Easy” (angelfish, yellow lab, Boesemani, Denison barb), “Moderate” (discus, firemouth, clown loach), “Difficult” (oscar); its discus text says it “requires an advanced level of care”. LA’s diet: “Carnivore” for discus and oscar, “Omnivore” for the rest; Aqueon calls discus omnivores, and Co-Op oscars.

Water Ranges Side by Side

SpeciespHTemperature (°F)
AngelfishAqueon (captive raised) 6.8-7.8; LA 5.8-7.0; Co-Op 6.0-8.0, “closer to the middle is always better”Aqueon 78-84; LA 75-82; Co-Op 78-86
DiscusAqueon 6.0-7.0; LA 6.1-7.5; Co-Op 6.8-7.6Aqueon 82-86; LA 79-86; Co-Op “85 to 86°F”
FiremouthLA 6.0-7.5; Aqueon, Central American cichlids: “usually above 7.6”LA 70-75; Aqueon, most New World cichlids: 75-80
Yellow labAqueon (Rift Lake water) 8.0-9.0; LA 7.8-8.5Aqueon 74-80; LA 72-82
BoesemaniAqueon (Melanotaeniids) 7.0-8.0; LA 7.0-8.0; Co-Op 6-8Aqueon 74-78; LA 72-77; Co-Op 75-82
Denison barbAqueon (barbs) 6.8-7.8; LA 6.8-7.8Aqueon 75-80; LA 60-77
Clown loachAqueon (loaches) 6.0-8.0; LA 6.0-7.5Aqueon: “vary depending on species”; LA 72-86; Co-Op 82-86
OscarLA 6.0-8.0; Co-Op 6-8LA 72-77; Co-Op 74-80

Aqueon says most Rift Lake and New World cichlids sold are commercially raised and “tolerate a wide range of water parameters”. Co-Op says of Boesemani rainbows: “They can go warmer, but higher temperatures tend to shorten their life span.”

Warning

Aqueon: “Mixing cichlids from other parts of the world with Rift Lake cichlids is not recommended, as they may require different water chemistry and they ‘speak different languages’, meaning they will try to communicate in ways the RLC’s do not understand, often resulting in harm to one or both fish.”

Groups, Temperament and Tank Mates

LA rates the discus, Boesemani and Denison barb “Peaceful” and the other five “Semi-Aggressive”.

  • Angelfish. Aqueon: they “can be kept in small groups in tanks of this size range”; they are “generally peaceful fish” but “can be aggressive toward one another, especially when attempting to pair off and spawn. Also, they will not hesitate to eat smaller fish.” Co-Op (55 gallons): “be prepared to remove some in the future if they get too territorial.”
  • Discus. Aqueon: “generally calm, peaceful fish”, but as cichlids “they can be aggressive toward one another, especially when attempting to pair off and spawn. Shy or submissive fish should be removed if they are unable to compete.” Co-Op starts a 75-gallon tank with “10 to 12 juveniles” and ends with “six adult discus”. On mates they differ: Aqueon says “Most serious hobbyists do not mix their discus with too many other species.”, then lists “clown loaches and dwarf cichlids” among suitable mates and says angelfish can be kept with discus “in larger aquariums, if the temperature is maintained above 82° F”; Co-Op says “Even other hot water fish like clown loaches, German blue rams, and angelfish can be too fast for them.”
  • Firemouth. LA: it “will harass smaller tank mates of their own species. It is therefore recommended to keep Firemouth Cichlids that are similar in size to minimize potential aggression.” Aqueon, for Central American cichlids in groups: “there will be more aggression when they pair off and breed”, and “it may be necessary to use a divider”.
  • Yellow lab. For Malawi cichlids in this size range, Aqueon suggests “harems” of “one or two males and several females” and says “It’s generally a good idea to crowd these fish to the capacity of the aquarium to reduce aggression.” Its Rift Lake guide: “Avoid adding more than one male of the same species, especially if females are present.” LA: it “will act aggressively towards fish of similar body shape and color”.
  • Boesemani rainbowfish. “groups of 6 or more” (Aqueon); “six or more rainbows of the same species if possible”, with “slightly more females than males” (Co-Op). Co-Op: “If given the chance, they will eat cherry shrimp, baby fish, and anything else that can fit in their mouths.”
  • Denison barb. Aqueon’s tank-size guide: “groups of 4 or more individuals in a tank with a lot of open swimming space”; its barb guide, for barbs generally, “schools of at least 6 to 10 fish”. Co-Op: “a group of 3–5 fish or more”.
  • Clown loach. Co-Op: with three, “they may hide a lot”; with 30, “they will be out all the time”. It calls them good community fish “as long as you do not put them with fish or invertebrates that are small enough to fit in their mouths”. Aqueon, for loaches generally: “if possible, should be purchased in groups of 6 or more”. Co-Op warns of “a retractable spike under each eye that can accidentally get caught in your fish net or hand if you need to move them”.
  • Oscar. Co-Op, on several in one tank: “If the situation doesn’t work out, then be prepared to remove some of the fish.” It says “do not keep them with nano creatures”, and that oscars “can be picked on by other big fish”. LA: they “will consume anything they can fit into their mouths”.

Three Fish Sources Say Outgrow 100 Gallons

  • Common pleco (Hypostomus plecostomus). Aqueon says it can grow to over 12 inches and “will eventually need an aquarium of at least 75 gallons”. Co-Op calls it “a nearly 2-foot beast” that “should probably start in a 75-gallon tank and eventually move up to 180 or even 500 gallons”. Co-Op adds: “do not release your common pleco into the wild because they are a highly invasive species and can do a lot of damage to the environment.”
  • Tinfoil barb. Aqueon: it “can get over a foot long”, and “Adult tinfoil barbs will eventually require a 125 gallon or larger aquarium.”
  • Giraffe catfish (Auchenoglanis occidentalis). Aqueon gives up to 24 inches and calls it “very peaceful and a suitable candidate for a big aquarium (at LEAST a 180-gallon)”.

Aqueon: “Don’t purchase fish on impulse. Make sure they won’t outgrow your tank, are compatible with existing tank inhabitants and you have the right food, equipment and skills to maintain them.” Co-Op: “bigger fish can be hard to rehome”.

How Many Fish Fit in 100 Gallons?

  • The inch rule. Co-Op says one inch of fish per gallon “mainly applies to small community fish that are approximately 1-3 inches (2-7 cm) in size”.
  • Test, don’t count. In a cycled tank, Co-Op’s “easiest way” is “measuring the nitrate level and making sure it stays below 40 ppm”. Aqueon: nitrate “levels above 50 ppm are undesirable in freshwater aquaria.”
  • Crowding. Aqueon: “Don’t overstock your aquarium. Fish that are crowded may fight, and overstocking can lead to water quality problems.” Its crowding advice above is for Malawi cichlids.

Before the First Fish: A Checklist

Must-haves

A cycling plan

API, a test-kit maker, describes a “fish in cycle” and a “fishless cycle”; see how to cycle a fish tank.

A filter sized for the tank

Aqueon: a filter “should have a flow rate at least four times the volume of the tank per hour”, and “Ideally” four to six times: 400 to 600 gallons per hour here (our arithmetic).

A test kit and conditioner

Aqueon: “Test the aquarium water for pH, ammonia and nitrite before adding new fish” and “Always treat tap water with a water conditioner to neutralize chlorine and ammonia before adding it to the aquarium.” It calls zero the only safe ammonia and nitrite level.

A heater and thermometer

Set to the ranges above; see our tank temperature guide.

A slow start

Aqueon: “only buy a few fish at a time. Wait at least a week between new fish additions.” See adding new fish.

A lid

Aqueon’s barb guide: “Keep a secure lid on the aquarium to prevent them from jumping out.” Co-Op wants “a tight lid” for Boesemani rainbows.

Nice-to-have

  • Rockwork for cichlids. Aqueon says structure helps “establish territorial boundaries”, and “Rocks and other large objects should be properly balanced or anchored to prevent them from falling and damaging the aquarium.”

What changes the list

  • Flow. Aqueon wants “gentle” water movement for discus and angelfish, but says “All loaches require clean, well oxygenated water with moderate to strong flow.”
  • Water chemistry. Rift Lake cichlids sit at the high-pH end of the table, discus at the low end; see Aqueon’s warning above and our checklist for choosing fish.

Ready to buy?

Our filter roundup notes that Modest Fish, a fishkeeping blog, recommends the Fluval FX6 for 100-200 gallons; see also our Filters & Media and Stocking sections.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. What is the king of aquarium fish?

Aqueon says discus are “sometimes referred to as” King of the Aquarium, but “are not for beginners”; Co-Op’s guide offers “tips for beginners starting their first discus tank”.

Q. What happens if I put too many fish in a tank?

Aqueon names “adding too many fish at once” as one reason ammonia rises in new tanks, and says it “can also rise in heavily populated tanks due to generous feeding and/or insufficient filtration”. Our high-ammonia guide covers the causes.

Q. How long after setting up a new tank can I add fish?

Aqueon: “Let a newly set up aquarium run for 2 to 3 days before purchasing your first fish”, and “Test the aquarium water for pH, ammonia and nitrite before adding new fish”. API says the nitrogen cycle “can take between 2-6 weeks to establish”.

Q. What should I do if a fish looks sick?

Test ammonia and nitrite first, and ask an aquatic veterinarian about the fish; disease and medication are outside what this site covers.

Sources (30)
Aquarium Tales Team
Aquarium Tales Team

Written and reviewed by the Aquarium Tales Team. See the About page for how we work.