10 Saltwater Aquarium Fish for Beginners: Sizes, Tank Minimums and Tank Mates

10 min read

The short answer

LiveAquaria, a marine fish retailer, rates the ocellaris clownfish, neon goby, firefish, royal gramma, pajama and Banggai cardinalfish, yellow watchman goby, blue-green chromis, orchid dottyback and bicolor blenny “Care Level: Easy”. Its minimum tanks run from 10 to 30 gallons; Coralife, an aquarium-products maker, gives smaller figures for some.

Each figure below is credited to the page it comes from, and where LiveAquaria (LA) and Coralife differ, both are shown. NOAA Fisheries, a US government agency, gives the Banggai cardinalfish’s status, and FishBase, a scientific fish database, confirms four of the scientific names. Our checklist for choosing fish covers the general questions, from freshwater sources.

The 10 Fish at a Glance

FishSize; minimum tankTemperament; reef (LA)
Ocellaris clownfish (Amphiprion ocellaris)3 in, 20 gal (LA); 2-3 in, 10 gal (Coralife)Peaceful; yes
Neon goby (Elacatinus oceanops)2 in, 10 gal (LA); about 2 in, 10 gal (Coralife)Peaceful; yes
Firefish (Nemateleotris magnifica)3 in, 20 gal (LA); up to 3 in, 10 gal (Coralife)Peaceful; yes
Royal gramma (Gramma loreto)3 in, 30 gal (LA); about 3 in, 30 gal (Coralife)Peaceful; yes
Pajama cardinalfish (Sphaeramia nematoptera)3.5 in, 20 or 30 gal (LA, see below); about 3.5 in, 10 gal alone (Coralife)Peaceful; yes
Banggai cardinalfish (Pterapogon kauderni)3 in, 30 gal (LA); up to 3.4 in (NOAA)Semi-aggressive; yes
Yellow watchman goby (Cryptocentrus cinctus)4 in, 30 gal (LA); up to 4 in, 30 gal for a pair (Coralife)Peaceful; yes
Blue-green chromis (Chromis viridis)4 in, 30 gal (LA); about 3 in, 30 gal (Coralife)Peaceful; yes
Orchid dottyback (Pseudochromis fridmani)3 in, 30 gal (LA)Semi-aggressive; yes
Bicolor blenny (Ecsenius bicolor)4 in, 30 gal (LA); about 4 in, 30 gal (Coralife)Peaceful; with caution

LA’s sizes are its “Maximum Size” figures. Its listings give the diet as omnivore for the clownfish and chromis, herbivore for the bicolor blenny and carnivore for the other seven. LA’s watchman figures come from its captive-bred spotted watchman goby, which it calls a “regional color variety of the Yellow Prawn Goby (Cryptocentrus cinctus)”.

Water Conditions on the Listings

All ten LA listings give the same water: “Temperature: 72 – 78° F”, “pH: 8.1 – 8.4”, “Specific Gravity: 1.020-1.025” and “dKH: 8 – 12”. These are one retailer’s listing ranges, repeated on every listing, not a standard for every fish or tank.

API, a test-kit maker, says “Fish waste, uneaten food, plant refuse and other organic compounds can create harmful levels of ammonia, nitrite and nitrate as well as cause drastic fluctuations in pH.” It says its Saltwater Master Test Kit “tests for high range pH, ammonia, nitrite, and nitrate”, and to “test weekly for best results”.

Note

If a fish looks sick, test the water and contact an aquatic veterinarian. Disease and treatment are outside what this site covers.

The Species, One by One

Ocellaris Clownfish (Amphiprion ocellaris)

LA’s ocellaris listing comes from Proaquatix, which LA calls “a top rated wholesaler of captive-bred Clownfish and other marine ornamentals”. It says “each Ocellaris Clownfish is captive-bred to help protect the fragile reef environments of the world”, and that these fish “can also be kept with a variety of other captive-bred clownfish, if introduced into the aquarium at the same time.” Coralife: “These fun-loving fish require at least a 10-gallon tank, but if you have more than one, you may want to consider something a little larger.” It adds that clownfish “love crevices and jumping — so a secure cover, such as a mesh lid, is a must.” The Spruce Pets, a pet publication, in an article by aquatic veterinarian Jessie Sanders, says “These easygoing reef fish like to have an anemone to call home but get along well with many species of fish.”

Neon Goby (Elacatinus oceanops)

LA: “Rarely will it become aggressive towards other fish, but it is territorial, and will fight with its own kind unless they are a mated pair.” Spruce: “They do well as a single fish or matched pair.” Coralife says neons “make particularly outstanding tankmates with clownfish and firefish gobies.” Biota, a marine aquaculture company that says “All Biota marine life is sustainably cultured in captivity”, sells captive-bred neon gobies from Proaquatix.

Firefish (Nemateleotris magnifica)

LA says it “is generally not aggressive towards other fish except those of its own species. However, a mated pair can live peacefully together.” It needs “multiple safety zones amongst rocky crags or outcroppings”, and “a stressed Firefish Goby will try to jump out of your aquarium. As such, house the Firefish Goby in aquarium systems with a lid.” Coralife: “you may want to avoid mixing firefish with damsels — they don’t always play well together.”

Royal Gramma (Gramma loreto)

LA: “Since it demonstrates territorial aggression towards its own kind, the Royal Gramma Basslet should be housed singly. However, most Royal Gramma Basslets are peaceful towards tankmates of similar size and temperament.” It prefers “extensive rockwork caves in which to hide and somewhat subdued lighting.” LA and Biota also sell Proaquatix royal grammas.

Pajama Cardinalfish (Sphaeramia nematoptera)

Sources differ on tank and group. LA’s quick stats say “Minimum Tank Size: 20 Gallons”, while its text says to keep them “in small schools in suitably sized aquariums of at least 30 gallons.” Coralife: “Cardinalfish travel in groups in the wild but can live comfortably alone in a 10-gallon tank.” LA calls it “a slow and methodical swimmer” that “should be housed with peaceful tankmates”. To train it onto flake, freeze-dried or pellet foods, Coralife says to “feed small amounts just before “lights out” to adapt them to dry foods.”

Banggai Cardinalfish (Pterapogon kauderni)

NOAA Fisheries: “In 2016, NOAA Fisheries listed the species as threatened under the Endangered Species Act.” It adds: “The main threats to the Banggai cardinalfish are harvest for the ornamental live reef trade and habitat destruction.” Spruce says “They are easily bred in captivity and enjoy a varied diet”, and Biota sells captive-bred Banggai cardinalfish. LA, which lists it as the Kaudern’s Cardinal and does not say whether its fish are captive-bred, says: “Due to its aggressive behavior towards conspecifics, the Kaudern’s Cardinal should not be kept in large groups.” It asks for “cave-like rockwork and peaceful tank mates”.

Yellow Watchman Goby (Cryptocentrus cinctus)

LA’s captive-bred spotted watchman listing asks for “plenty of loose coral rubble, ample swimming room, and a sand bottom for burrowing”, and says “Watchman Gobies are peaceful but can become aggressive and territorial with its own kind unless they are a mated pair.” It adds that “a tight-fitting lid is required to prevent escape.” Coralife says they “love to burrow with their favorite tank mate, the pistol shrimp”. Biota sells captive-bred yellow watchman gobies.

Blue-Green Chromis (Chromis viridis)

Sources differ on group size. LA describes “a small school of Blue Green Reef Chromis comprised of at least six individuals” in “almost any well-established reef system”. Coralife: “These shiny beauties prefer to live in small groups (three to five fish), so a 30-gallon tank or larger is best.” Coralife also warns: “While these omnivores are reef-safe, they have been known to nibble on growing invertebrates, so keep watch until your tank fully matures.” Biota sells captive-bred chromis.

Orchid Dottyback (Pseudochromis fridmani)

LA sells it captive-bred from Proaquatix and says: “It may occasionally chase smaller fish but will defend its hiding places from intruders.” It also says “If more than one Pseudochromis will be maintained together in the aquarium, it is important to add them at the same time.” LA lists it “Semi-Aggressive” and asks for “numerous hiding places”.

Bicolor Blenny (Ecsenius bicolor)

LA lists it “Reef Compatible: With Caution”. It says “These fishes are normally peaceful tank members, but have been known to pick at other blennies, smaller gobies and dartfish.” It advises caution in smaller setups or with smaller fleshy corals, because these blennies have picked at clam mantles and fleshy large-polyp stony corals “when underfed”; “In larger reef aquariums they rarely do damage to these corals or clams.” Coralife says they “will occasionally nibble on clams and large stony corals if underfed.” Spruce names blennies and jawfish among fish that “cannot swim against a powerful flow for long periods.”

Three More Fish, with Their Cautions

Coralife’s beginner list also includes the first two; the cautions below are the sources’ own.

  • Sixline wrasse. Coralife: “While wrasses are peaceful, they can become mildly aggressive with newly added fish, so they should be one of the last fish added to the tank.” It gives a size of about 3 inches and a 10-gallon aquarium.
  • Yellowtail blue damsel. Coralife calls it hardy, small (about 2.5 inches) and “usually peaceful”, and says these fish “require at least a 20-gallon tank for an individual and a bit larger if kept in small groups.” Coralife gives no aggression caution for it; the warnings that follow are about other damsels. LA, on the blue damselfish (Chrysiptera cyanea): “As the Blue Damselfish matures, it may demonstrate pronounced territorial behavior towards future additions to the aquarium.” Spruce, on damselfish in general: “Damselfish need to have their own cave or they will not flourish in your aquarium.”
  • Coral beauty angelfish (Centropyge bispinosa). Not on Coralife’s list. LA rates it “Care Level: Easy” but gives “Minimum Tank Size: 70 Gallons” and says “Not a good reef dweller, the Coral Beauty Angelfish is prone to nip at stony and soft corals (sessile invertebrates).”

Before the First Fish: A Checklist

Must-haves

A test kit that reads salt water

API’s Saltwater Master Test Kit covers pH, ammonia, nitrite and nitrate; for reef tanks API says “for best results, it is recommended that you use API REEF MASTER TEST KIT.” Our test kit roundup is freshwater-first and marks kits labeled for both fresh and marine water, and our liquid kits vs test strips comparison notes which are also sold for salt water.

A tight lid

LA calls for one with the watchman goby and the firefish; Coralife calls a secure cover “a must” for clownfish and says of watchman gobies, “when they’re not burrowing, they’re jumping!”

Rock with caves

LA asks for caves or hiding places for the royal gramma, firefish, both cardinalfish and the orchid dottyback.

The whole stock list, planned at adult size

Spruce: “Never put a fish in a tank and tell yourself, “I’ll get a bigger tank later,” because most people won’t. Plan ahead or don’t add that particular fish.”

An order of adding

LA says captive-bred clownfish, and dottybacks kept together, go in at the same time; Coralife adds the sixline wrasse last.

Nice-to-haves

  • A sand bed and a pistol shrimp for a watchman goby (LA’s sand bottom; Coralife’s “favorite tank mate”).
  • An anemone for clownfish. Spruce: “Keeping anemones and other soft corals in an aquarium comes with their list of requirements and parameters, so take those into consideration when designing your tank.”

What changes the list

  • Reef or fish-only: the bicolor blenny is “With Caution” on LA, chromis may nibble growing invertebrates (Coralife), and LA says the coral beauty nips corals.
  • Tank size: LA’s minimum is 10 gallons only for the neon goby. Coralife names 10 gallons for the clownfish, neon goby, firefish, sixline wrasse and a single pajama cardinalfish.
  • Water flow: Spruce says “some spots may need to be lower flow.”

Ready to buy?

Our Saltwater & Reef section gathers the marine gear guides, and the Stocking section has more on which fish suit a tank.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. What is the easiest saltwater fish for a beginner?

LA rates all ten fish above “Care Level: Easy”. Coralife opens its list with the ocellaris clownfish, calling it “One of the best and most popular fish (thanks to animated movies) for a newly established saltwater tank”.

Q. What saltwater fish suit a small tank?

By LA’s minimums: the neon goby at 10 gallons, then the ocellaris clownfish, firefish and pajama cardinalfish (quick stats) at 20. Coralife’s 10-gallon figures are in the table and the checklist above.

Q. Can a shark live in a home saltwater aquarium?

Spruce puts the black banded cat shark (Chiloscyllium punctatum) under “Incompatible Tankmates” and says “All sharks and rays require a large volume of water.” None of the fish on this list is a shark.

Q. Which of these fish are best kept one per tank?

LA says the royal gramma “should be housed singly”, and that the neon goby and watchman goby can be territorial with their own kind unless they are a mated pair. Coralife says of firefish: “Adult firefish generally enjoy “the single life,” so one fish may be sufficient.”

Sources (27)
Aquarium Tales Team
Aquarium Tales Team

Written and reviewed by the Aquarium Tales Team. See the About page for how we work.