Which Aquarium Snails Are Best? 7 Freshwater Species Compared

15 min read

The short answer

For algae with little risk of a population boom, Aqueon points to nerite snails, whose larvae need brackish or salt water. Mystery snails lay removable egg clusters above the water; rabbit snails breed slowly; assassin snails eat other snails. Ramshorn, bladder and Malaysian trumpet snails clean up but reproduce quickly. Sources differ on sizes, tanks and invasiveness.

Aquarium Co-Op (Co-Op), LiveAquaria (LA) and The Shrimp Farm (SF) are aquarium livestock retailers, and Aqueon is an aquarium-products maker. The US Geological Survey’s Nonindigenous Aquatic Species database (USGS), the University of Florida’s IFAS Extension service (UF/IFAS) and Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant, a university program, cover snails in the wild. Where sources give different figures, each appears under its own name. Everything here is for freshwater tanks.

If snails turned up in your tank without being bought, our guide to why snails appear in an aquarium covers how they get in.

The Seven Snails at a Glance

Each source measures in its own way: Co-Op, Aqueon and SF give mystery snail sizes as shell diameter. Figures after ≈ are our conversions from metric. Names in the first column are a genus (Pomacea, Tylomelania), a family (Neritidae, Planorbidae, Physidae) or a species (Melanoides tuberculata, Clea helena).

SnailAdult size, by sourceMinimum tank, by source
Mystery snail (Pomacea)2-2.5 in (Co-Op list); about 2 in (Co-Op care guide); “a little over 1½ inch” (Aqueon); 1.5 in (LA); about 2.5 in (SF)5 gal for one or two (Co-Op); 10 gal (LA); 10 gal plus 2.5 gal per extra snail (SF)
Nerite snail (Neritidae)0.5-1.5 in (Co-Op); 1 in, zebra nerite (LA, SF)2-3 gal (Co-Op); 10 gal (LA); 5 gal for racer and horned nerites (SF)
Ramshorn snail (Planorbidae)1-2 in (Co-Op); about 1.5 in for most (SF)5 gal (SF)
Malaysian trumpet snail (Melanoides tuberculata)1 in (Co-Op); average shell 20-27 mm ≈0.8-1.1 in, maximum 80 mm ≈3.1 in (USGS)not given
Rabbit snail (Tylomelania)3-5 in (Co-Op); up to 4 in for some species (Aqueon); 3 in, gold rabbit (LA)20 gal (Aqueon); 30 gal (LA); over 10 gal, golden rabbit (SF)
Assassin snail (Clea helena)1 in (Co-Op, Aqueon)5 gal (SF)
Bladder snail (Physidae)under 1 in (Co-Op)not given

Water, Care and Diet by Source

Co-Op’s general rule for snails: “Because snails need certain minerals like calcium for proper shell development, they tend to prefer higher pH above 7.0 and higher GH above 8° (140 ppm).” SF adds that “Overly acidic water can cause their shells to deteriorate”. LA’s figures come from its product pages for the gold mystery, zebra nerite and gold rabbit snails.

SnailTemperature, by sourcepH, by source
Mystery70-78°F (Co-Op); 68-84°F (LA)“at least 7.2” (Co-Op); 7.8-8.4 (LA)
Nerite“a wide range of tropical temperatures” (Co-Op); 65-85°F (LA)above 7.0 (Co-Op); 6.5-8.0 (LA)
Ramshornnot givennot given
Malaysian trumpetoptimum 18-32°C ≈64-90°F (USGS, citing a USDA-ARS researcher’s personal communication)not given
Rabbit80-86°F (Co-Op); 76-84°F (Aqueon); 68-74°F (LA)7.8-8.4 (Aqueon); 6.5-7.5 (LA)
Assassinnot givennot given
Bladder“a wide range” (Co-Op)“a wide range” (Co-Op)

Co-Op’s mystery snail guide also asks for “GH above 150 ppm (or 8 degrees)”. We left out LiveAquaria’s assassin snail size, tank, temperature, pH and care level: its stat block is identical to its gold rabbit snail block, down to the family (Pachychilidae), and its own text gives a purchase size of 1/4 to 1-1/4 inches. No other source here gives an assassin temperature or pH.

SnailCare level; temperamentDiet and plants
MysteryEasy; Peaceful (LA)LA: “algae, plants, vegetables, flake food, frozen foods, and live foods”. Co-Op: they won’t eat your plants, duckweed aside
NeriteEasy; Peaceful (LA)Algae, leftover food, dead plant matter; “they don’t eat plants” (Aqueon)
Ramshornnot ratedAlgae, fish food, melting leaves (Co-Op); soft-leafed plants “when food is scarce” (Aqueon)
Malaysian trumpet“extremely hardy” (Co-Op)“microalgae and detritus” (USGS); won’t eat plants (Aqueon)
RabbitModerate; Peaceful (LA)Soft algae, detritus, sinking foods (Aqueon); softer plants if underfed (Co-Op); Java fern reports (Aqueon, LA)
Assassinnot rated; “a peaceful community tank resident” (LA text)“other snails or carrion” (Aqueon); “Opportunistic carnivores” (LA text)
Bladder“not fussy” about water (Co-Op)Algae, leftover food, fish waste (Co-Op, for pest snails)

Which Snails Will Fill the Tank?

SnailHow it breedsIn a freshwater tank
MysterySeparate sexes: “you need a boy and a girl” (Aqueon); eggs laid above the water line“the large egg cluster can be removed if babies are not desired” (Co-Op)
NeriteSeparate sexes (Co-Op)Eggs “won’t hatch in fresh water” (Co-Op); “impossible in freshwater!” (LA)
Ramshorn“simultaneous hermaphrodites” (Co-Op)“can multiply quickly, especially in aquariums that have a lot of organic debris” (Aqueon)
BladderHermaphrodites “that can fertilize themselves” (Co-Op)Co-Op links a population explosion to “feeding the aquarium too much”
Malaysian trumpet“females can create clones without the presence of males” (Co-Op)“virtually impossible to get rid of once they enter your aquarium” (Aqueon)
RabbitLive young; an egg pod “once every 4 to 6 weeks” (Aqueon)“their reproductive rate is very slow” (Aqueon)
AssassinSeparate sexes; “females only lay 1 to 4 eggs at a time” (Aqueon)“Reproduction is slow” (Aqueon)

For mystery snails the figures for the gap above the water differ, partly because the goals differ. Co-Op, to stop breeding: “Keep the water level in the fish tank within 1.5 inches (4 cm) or less from the top so that they do not have room to lay their eggs out of the water.” LA: “Two to four inches of open air space above the waterline in the aquarium is required as this snail needs open air to breathe.” Co-Op’s guide also says to “Drop the water line by at least 3–4 inches” from the top when you want eggs, so its gap depends on whether you want breeding.

Snail by Snail: What Each Source Adds

Mystery Snail (Pomacea diffusa or P. bridgesii)

Aqueon names two species in the trade, “Pomacea bridgesii and Pomacea diffusa, with P. diffusa thought to be the most common one”. Co-Op’s snail list names P. bridgesii and its care guide both, SF names P. diffusa and LA gives “Pomacea sp.”; UF/IFAS says P. diffusa “is marketed as an aquarium species under the name” golden applesnail. Co-Op’s one plant exception: “There are many recorded accounts of mystery snails eating duckweed and other small floating plants”. Aqueon: “A secure lid should be used to prevent them from climbing out of the tank.” Co-Op: “do not keep them with snail eaters like puffer fish, certain loaches, and turtles”.

Nerite Snail (Neritina, Vittina and Relatives)

Co-Op calls nerites “one of the best algae eaters in the freshwater aquarium hobby”, able to eat green spot algae, but warns that “if there is not enough algae in the tank, they can potentially starve to death”; it suggests “canned green beans, blanched zucchini slices” and a food block as extras. “They are prone to escaping, so keep a tight lid on your aquarium.” Aqueon groups them as Neritina; SF gives the zebra nerite as Vittina natalensis.

Ramshorn Snail (Planorbidae)

Aqueon says the two most common in the trade are “the Red Ramshorn and Planorbarius corneus, a larger species known as the Great Ramshorn”. SF says the name “is used very loosely” and that the giant ramshorn, Marisa cornuarietis, belongs to the mystery snail family. On plants the sources split: Co-Op says bladder, ramshorn and trumpet snails “will not harm your live fish or plants”, while Aqueon says ramshorns “are also known to eat soft-leafed plants when food is scarce.”

Malaysian Trumpet Snail (Melanoides tuberculata)

USGS notes that the official name is Melanoides tuberculatus, “often spelled as Melanoides tuberculata”. Co-Op calls it “a mostly nocturnal snail” that spends much of its time burrowed, and says many keepers like that “they regularly turn over the sand or gravel”. They are hard to remove once in: Co-Op says they “have been known to survive in dry, used gravel for many months”, and Aqueon that they “are known to live in buckets of used gravel for over a year!”

Rabbit Snail (Tylomelania)

For rabbit snails the water figures do not agree: LA’s temperature range overlaps neither Co-Op’s nor Aqueon’s, and its pH range does not overlap Aqueon’s. Aqueon: “Some aquarists mix crushed coral into the gravel or place coral in their filters to achieve the correct water chemistry.” On plants, Co-Op says “they may start to nibble on plants with softer leaves and stems if not fed enough. However, they seem to do fine with tougher, thicker plants like anubias.” Aqueon notes “anecdotal reports of them nibbling on Java Fern”, and LA mentions them “occasionally eating aquarium plants like Java Ferns”.

Assassin Snail (Clea helena)

SF gives the name as “Clea helena, formerly Anentome helena”; Co-Op uses Anentome helena. Co-Op warns that “groups of assassin snails are capable of taking down snails that are much larger than themselves”, and SF says “you shouldn’t keep assassin snails in an aquarium that also houses other ornamental snails”. On shrimp, Aqueon: “A few shrimp breeders have reported seeing Assassin snails eating their valuable shrimp, but experts believe that this happens very rarely, and the victims are most likely weak or sickly.” SF: “Opinions vary on whether assassins are 100% shrimp-safe”. For a pest-snail outbreak, LA suggests “ideally 5 snails for every 15 gallons in your system”; our guide to getting rid of snails without chemicals covers the other methods.

Bladder Snail (Physidae)

Co-Op says bladder snails “are not fussy about water parameters” and are sometimes confused with larger pond snails, “which can grow to 2–3 inches (5–8 cm) and like to eat aquarium plants.”

Invasive Snails: What the Agencies Say

One 2014 brochure from Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant, a university program based in two Great Lakes states, lists snails to buy and to avoid. The brochure does not say which regions the lists cover, so read them as one source’s view. It warns: “Many snails, clams and mussels used in classroom and home aquariums are invasive.” Because “These common names can refer to both invasive and non-invasive species”, it says knowing the scientific name “will allow you to avoid buying known invaders”. Its two lists, which it bases on research at Loyola University Chicago, the University of Notre Dame and The Nature Conservancy:

  • Purchase these non-invaders (Sea Grant, 2014; snails): the ghost ramshorn (Biomphalaria havanensis), assassin snail (Clea helena), horned nerite (Clithon corona), rigid ramshorn (Drepanotrema cimex), giant ramshorn (Marisa cornuarietis), red-rimmed melania (Melanoides tuberculata, the Malaysian trumpet snail), zebra, tiger and batik nerites (Nerita natalensis group), olive nerite (Neritina reclivata), Seminole or American ramshorn (Planorbella duryi), quilted melania (Tarebia granifera) and eight rabbit snails (Tylomelania).
  • Avoid these known or potential invaders (Sea Grant, 2014; snails): the Chinese mystery snail or Japanese trapdoor snail (Bellamya chinensis), Japanese mystery snail (Bellamya japonica), two-ridge ramshorn (Helisoma anceps), pond snail (Lymnaea peregra), common bladder snail (Physa fontinalis), European physa (Physella acuta), ramshorn snail (Planorbis contortus) and Pomacea bridgesii, listed as “spiketop applesnail, mystery snail”. The list also names two mussels and a clam.

Neither list names P. diffusa, the species Aqueon thinks most common among mystery snails.

USGS, by contrast, lists Melanoides tuberculata as established in the wild in 14 states and Puerto Rico (our count of its list) and says “Some of the early known populations most likely began from local aquarium hobbyists’ releases.” UF/IFAS says aquarium P. diffusa snails “are sometimes dumped into isolated bodies of water”.

Larger apple snails are a separate concern. Aqueon: “Some species of apple snails (Pomacea) are voracious herbivores that will decimate a planted aquarium in short order. Apple snails have also caused damage to crops in certain parts of the world after being inadvertently introduced into the wild.” USGS says the giant applesnail (Pomacea maculata; island applesnail in UF/IFAS) “Can reach 155 mm in shell height” (≈6.1 in) and that “the species was likely introduced via the aquarium trade”.

Warning

UF/IFAS Extension’s applesnail fact sheet (no publication date; it cites a 2006 source) says: “Effective 5 April 2006, USDA-APHIS requires permits for importation or interstate shipment of all marine and freshwater snails. Permits are not being issued for members of the genus Pomacea, with the exception of the spike-topped applesnail, Pomacea diffusa (FFWCC 2006). To ship any of these species without a permit is a violation of United States federal law.” We could not check this against USDA-APHIS itself, so it may have changed. Confirm with USDA-APHIS or your state wildlife agency before shipping or buying Pomacea snails. The fact sheet also says: “Never release applesnails from aquaria into the wild”. Sea Grant: “Never release aquatic plants or animals into waterways!” For snails you no longer want, Sea Grant says: “Find new homes for unwanted pets, such as schools, retailers or other hobbyists.” It also says to contact a veterinarian or pet retailer “for guidance on humane disposal of animals”, and points to takeAIM.org “to learn about species regulations for your state”.

Your Snail Checklist

Check these first

Know the scientific name

Ask the seller for it and compare it with Sea Grant’s lists above. The same snail can carry different scientific names (see the nerite and mystery sections), so match it as exactly as you can. For any Pomacea apple snail, read the UF/IFAS permit note first.

Fit a tight lid

Co-Op: “make sure you have a tight-fitting lid, cover any openings with craft mesh, and consider lowering the water level if needed.” This is Co-Op’s escape advice; for mystery snails it conflicts with the 1.5 in gap above.

Test pH and hardness before you choose

Compare your readings with each species’ ranges above; Aqueon: “Test water chemistry regularly to make sure you are providing the right conditions for all your aquatic pets.” Our roundup of freshwater test kits compares kits, and our guide to raising GH in an aquarium covers hardness.

Leave out snail eaters

Co-Op: “avoid snail-eating predators such as certain loaches and pufferfish.”

Plan the food

Aqueon: “Snails naturally feed on algae, dead plant matter and bits of fish food that fall to the bottom”, and “Feed sparingly and remove uneaten food to avoid water quality problems.” Nerites can starve without algae (Co-Op). See what aquarium snails eat.

Pick a breeding pace you can live with

Use the breeding table above.

Nice to have

  • Calcium-rich vegetables: Aqueon names “blanched kale, spinach, Chinese cabbage, green beans or broccoli, as these vegetables are all rich in calcium”.
  • A lifespan you are ready for: Aqueon says mystery snails “live 3 to 4 years”; Co-Op gives “an average life span of 1–2 years, depending on the water temperature.” Our snail lifespan chart by species covers the others.

What changes the list

  • A planted tank: check the plant column above; Aqueon warns that some apple snails “decimate a planted aquarium”.
  • A shrimp tank: weigh the assassin snail reports from Aqueon and SF.
  • Soft or acidic water: Co-Op says mystery snails “cannot live in soft water environments”; SF warns about shell damage in acidic water.
  • A small tank: the minimum-tank figures differ most for nerites (2-3 gal, Co-Op; 10 gal, LA) and mystery snails (5 gal for one or two, Co-Op; 10 gal, LA and SF).
  • Pest snails already in the tank: Aqueon calls assassin snails “a natural method for reducing nuisance snail populations”, but Co-Op warns that groups also take larger snails.

More species-choice guides sit in our Stocking section.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. Which snails are best for cleaning a tank?

Co-Op says snails “help to clean up and break down organics in the tank, such as leftover fish food, dying plant leaves, algae, and even deceased animals.” Among the seven, Co-Op singles out nerites for algae, including green spot algae, and trumpet snails for turning over the substrate.

Q. Are nerite or ramshorn snails better?

They differ mainly in breeding. Nerite eggs do not hatch in fresh water (Co-Op), while Aqueon says ramshorns “can multiply quickly, especially in aquariums that have a lot of organic debris.”

Q. What snails are bad for a fish tank?

Aqueon says no snail is truly bad, but “a few species can multiply unchecked and overrun an aquarium”, naming Malaysian trumpet and ramshorn snails. For invasive species, see Sea Grant’s avoid list above.

Q. Which aquarium snails don’t reproduce in a tank?

Nerite eggs do not hatch in fresh water (Co-Op, LA); rabbit and assassin snails breed slowly (Aqueon). A lone mystery snail cannot breed, though Co-Op notes females store sperm.

Q. How many snails should I put in my tank?

These sources give figures per species, not one rule. SF says a mystery snail needs “a tank of 10 gallons or up, counting 2.5 extra gallons for each additional specimen”, and Co-Op says “one or two” can live in 5 gallons.

Q. What is the easiest snail to keep?

LA rates the gold mystery and zebra nerite snails “Care Level: Easy”. Co-Op, a retailer, says its favorite is the olive nerite because, from its own experience, it is “one of the hardiest and easiest types to keep.”

Q. What is the largest snail I can legally keep in the US?

None of the sources here gives a size limit or a list of snails that are legal to keep. UF/IFAS covers shipping, not keeping: USDA-APHIS permits to import or ship snails between states are “not being issued for members of the genus Pomacea”, except P. diffusa (see the warning above). For what your state allows, Sea Grant points to takeAIM.org, or ask your state wildlife agency. For size alone, Co-Op gives rabbit snails the largest figures (3-5 in).

Sources (14)
Aquarium Tales Team
Aquarium Tales Team

Written and reviewed by the Aquarium Tales Team. See the About page for how we work.