How Many Fish Can Go in a 20-Gallon Tank? A Stocking Checklist

12 min read

The short answer

There is no fixed number. AQQA, an aquarium equipment brand, says most 20-gallon tanks “can safely handle somewhere between 10 to 20 small fish”, depending on species, adult size, temperament, filtration and planting. Aqueon, an aquarium-products maker, gives a “general rule of thumb” of “one inch of adult size fish per net gallon”, with more space for territorial fish.

Every figure below is a rule of thumb with conditions attached. This checklist sets the counts side by side, then covers what changes the number in your tank and how to check it with a test kit as you stock. For which species suit 20 gallons, see our guide to fish for a 20-gallon tank.

None of the counts here comes from a saltwater guide; saltwater comes near the end.

The Counts Sources Give for 20 Gallons

SourceWhat it saysIts condition
AQQA (equipment brand)“somewhere between 10 to 20 small fish”Depends on species, adult size, temperament, filtration and planting
Bubble-Magus (equipment brand)“up to 10–15 smaller fish, or a few medium-sized species”“With a well-planned stocking list and proper filtration”
Aqueon (maker)“one inch of adult size fish per net gallon”“territorial fish need even more space”
Aquarium Co-Op (retailer)Inch per gallon “mainly applies to small community fish”Fish of about 1-3 inches

AQQA’s own table splits its range: “Light” is “8–12 small fish”, “Moderate” is “12–18 nano fish”, and “18–22 small fish” is “Heavy (Experienced)”, with “Frequent monitoring, strong filtration”. It also says a standard 20-gallon’s surface area “supports way fewer fish than that old “1 inch per gallon” rule everyone throws around, especially if you’re keeping active fish that swim a lot.” Our checklist for choosing fish sets the CDC, RSPCA and TFH versions of the inch rule side by side, with their caveats.

The “net” in Aqueon’s rule matters: a tank holds less water than its label once glass, gravel and decorations are counted. Our tank volume guide explains the gap between inside, outside and label gallons.

Must-Haves Before You Count

Look up each species’ adult size

Aquarium Co-Op says most fish “are sold as juveniles at the fish store and may double or triple in size by the time they reach maturity”. TFH, a fishkeeping magazine owned by Aqueon’s parent company, Central Garden & Pet, says to “research how big each will ultimately get”. AQQA’s example is a molly bought at one inch: “It’s going to hit 3 to 4 inches and start producing way more waste once it grows up.”

Weigh body bulk and waste, not just inches

Co-Op: “ten 1-inch tetras do not have the same body volume as one 10-inch oscar.” AqAdvisor, an online stocking calculator (more on it below), gives each species a bioload factor because “species of the same size don’t always produce same amount of waste.”

Count the whole school

Aqueon: “Always buy schooling fish in groups of 6 or more.” Co-Op says some schooling species “prefer to live in groups of at least 6 to 10 fish, so consider the impact that has on the overall waste load.”

Check temperament and territory

Aqueon: “When fish are crowded they become more agitated and are more likely to quarrel with tank mates.” For 20 to 50 gallons, it says that with fish in the 3-4 inch range “sometimes their natural territoriality and aggression can be a concern, so care must still be made to not overcrowd them.” The CDC, the US federal health agency, adds: “Some types of fish, like male betta fish, can’t be in the same aquarium together because they will fight.” Aqueon names one exception: “While most fish get along better when they have more space, African Rift Lake Cichlids are an exception; they do best when crowded a little as this deters dominant fish from singling out weaker or submissive fish.” That line is from Aqueon’s general compatibility page; its tank-size guide covers the East African cichlids in its 55-120 gallon section, so it is no reason to crowd a 20-gallon tank (our reading).

Size the filter for the load

Aqueon: “A hardworking filter should have a flow rate at least four times the volume of the tank per hour to keep the water clean. If your tank has fewer fish or fish that don’t eat as much food or as often, a filter that runs the water through at this rate should do the job fine.” Four times the label’s 20 gallons is 80 gallons per hour (our arithmetic). AQQA suggests “a filter rated for 30 to 40 gallons” for a 20-gallon tank (a tank-size rating, not a flow rate), and Bubble-Magus says “the larger the bioload (i.e., the number of fish), the more filtration you’ll need.” Our fish tank filter roundup compares hang-on-back, canister and sponge filters.

Match water ranges and diets

The CDC: “Don’t forget to research which species of fish can be in the same tank together and what types of food they will need.” AqAdvisor compares the “Water pH, temperature and hardness” ranges of the species you pick and shows a warning on a conflict.

Cycle the tank and own a test kit

Aqueon: “Adding too many fish at once or overfeeding a new freshwater aquarium will cause ammonia and nitrite to rise to unsafe levels – a condition known as “New Tank Syndrome” – and may result in fish loss.” It says “The only safe ammonia level is zero” and “The only safe nitrite level is zero.” See how to cycle a fish tank and our freshwater test kit roundup.

Nice-to-Haves That Add Margin

  • Live plants. Co-Op: “The more plants you have, the more fish the aquarium can handle.” It adds that “fast-growing plants like stem plants and floating plants remove nitrogen waste more rapidly than slow-growing plants.” AQQA cautions that “too many rocks and decorations eat up space where fish need to swim, which means less fish overall.”
  • More frequent water changes. Co-Op: “The more frequently you change water in your aquarium, the more fish you will be able to keep.” See how often to change fish tank water.
  • Feeding that makes less waste. Co-Op: “the more food you feed the aquarium (whether you have lots of little fish or one big fish), the more poop is produced.” It says low-quality foods “contain a lot of filler ingredients that are not digestible, which create more waste.” For a new tank, Aqueon’s rule of thumb is to “feed only what the fish can consume in 2 minutes or less.” Our tropical fish food roundup compares flakes, granules and pellets, and our guide to what fish food is made of covers ingredients by food type.
  • Room to spare. Co-Op’s advice is to “Aim to understock your fish tank”, and AQQA’s: “Start with fewer fish than you think.” TFH gives one reason: a more conservatively stocked new aquarium “will be more resilient to oxygen interruptions, such as a power outage or a filter breaking, because the smaller population has a lower oxygen demand than would the population in a heavily stocked aquarium.”

Long or High: Same Gallons, Different Room

Aqueon’s sizing chart lists its 20 High at 24¼ x 12½ x 16¾ inches and its 20 Long at 30¼ x 12½ x 12¾ inches (length x width x height). That gives the Long about 378 square inches of footprint to the High’s 303, roughly a quarter more (our arithmetic, from the outside dimensions).

TFH: “Aquariums that are shallower but have a larger footprint can house more fish than tall aquariums because there is better surface gas exchange, and the fish have more room to move around and stake out territories on the bottom.” The RSPCA, a UK animal welfare charity, agrees that “wide tanks are better than tall tanks as they have a larger surface area for the water volume.” Aqueon says wider tanks give “active fish, like danios and barbs, the space to spread out”, while tall, narrow tanks “don’t offer fish as much swimming space or territory as a wider aquarium” and “should be used for less active fish like discus, angelfish and gouramis” (for angelfish in 20 gallons, see the FAQ).

AQQA’s suggestion by shape: the Long is “Better for fish that swim around a lot, like tetras”, and the High “Works well for tall plants and fish that stay near the bottom”.

How to Check the Count as You Stock

Aquarium Co-Op gives this method for a tank that is already cycled. Aqueon’s readings are added at the test step.

Plan the whole list first

Co-Op: find out whether the species “are all compatible with each other in terms of temperament, size, aggression level, living conditions, and similar diet.” A calculator can help with this step (below).

Pick a water-change routine

Co-Op’s next step: “Choose a set frequency at which you plan to do water changes.”

Add one species first

Co-Op: “Add your favorite species first. If it is a schooling fish, consider adding the minimum recommended number at first to make sure the aquarium can handle the waste load.” In a new tank, Aqueon says to “only buy a few fish at a time. Wait at least a week between new fish additions.” Our guide to adding new fish covers acclimation.

Test weekly before the next species

Co-Op: “Measure the nitrate level each week for 2 to 3 weeks in a row.” Its signal for the next species is that “you can consistently keep the nitrate level below 40 ppm”, with ammonia and nitrite at zero (Aqueon, above). Seachem, a maker of aquarium water-care products, gives a similar ceiling: “As a general rule, nitrate levels should not be allowed to build up far above around 40 mg/L regardless of the system.” (API, a test-kit maker, says its kit reads ppm “which are equivalent to milligrams per liter”.) Aqueon draws its line higher: “Nitrate toxicity to fish varies depending on species, age and overall health, but levels above 50 ppm are undesirable in freshwater aquaria.” Seachem adds that how much is too much “will vary from system to system” and says to “Research your fish to know their level of nitrate sensitivity”. Aqueon also says “Some tap water sources are high in nitrate, so it is a good idea to test your tap water before using it.”

Repeat, and stop when readings climb

Co-Op repeats the add-and-test steps for each further species. Aqueon notes ammonia “can also rise in heavily populated tanks due to generous feeding and/or insufficient filtration”, and its new-tank guide introduces more fish “Once ammonia and nitrite levels return to zero”. Add no fish while either reads above zero; follow our guide to lowering ammonia, and keep testing until both read zero. For nitrate, see why nitrate runs high. If a fish looks sick, test the water and contact an aquatic veterinarian.

Stocking Calculators: What They Check

AqAdvisor (aqadvisor.com) is an online calculator written by Yeo-Hoon Bae and supported by Amazon commissions. You choose a tank from a list with several 20-gallon shapes, among them “20g high”, “20g long” and “20g x high”, add your filter and species, and it says it will calculate bioload and filtration capacity, recommend a water-change schedule and “determine compatibility between selected aquarium species.” It states that it “does NOT use the simple (but flawed) inch-per gallon rule.”

Its own cautions come first, though: “It’s not perfect!” and “This tool is not a replacement for experienced keepers’ advices.” It recommends that new tropical fish keepers understock, below 100% on its scale, and says: “Use AqAdvisor.com to get general stocking recommendations but do your own research BEFORE buying any species.” Its explainer page was last updated in April 2010, by its own date line.

What Changes the Count

  • Breeding and growth. Co-Op: “Some species breed quite readily and the population boom may increase the waste load, so you may need to remove fish to compensate.” Plants change it too: they grow, “which decreases the waste load but cuts into the available swimming space.” For its livebearer tank, AQQA suggests the lower counts because “you might get overwhelmed with a lot of babies that just don’t stop.”
  • Goldfish. Sources disagree: Aqueon’s tank-size guide calls 20-50 gallons “an excellent tank size range for fancy Goldfish”, while AQQA’s answer for goldfish in 20 gallons is “Zero. They make way too much waste and really need 40 to 55 gallons at a minimum to stay healthy.” The strictest for a 20-gallon tank is AQQA’s (our reading); our 20-gallon species guide sets out each source’s per-fish figures.
  • Saltwater tanks. The table’s sources give no separate saltwater count. Habitattitude, a public education campaign sponsored by Pet Advocacy Network, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and NOAA: “Most saltwater fish need a minimum of 29-gallon tanks. Dartfish, Gobies and Damselfish (Indo-Pacific species) can be kept in smaller marine aquaria.”

Ready to buy?

Our fish tank filter roundup compares hang-on-back, canister and sponge filters, and our Stocking section gathers our guides to choosing fish and stocking tanks by size.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. How many tetras can I put in a 20-gallon tank?

Sources differ, and so do AQQA’s own answers. Bubble-Magus lists a “Small school of Tetras (8–10 fish, such as Neon or Rummy Nose Tetras)” as one part of its 20-gallon community idea. AQQA’s FAQ says of neon tetras, “Around 15 to 20 works because they are small and do well in schools.” Its community setup on the same page lists “8–10 Neon Tetras or Ember Tetras” beside a centerpiece fish and corydoras, and its table calls 18 to 22 small fish “Heavy (Experienced)” stocking.

Q. How many fish can go in a 20-gallon long tank?

None of the sources here gives a separate count for the Long; see the footprint comparison above.

Q. How many angelfish can go in a 20-gallon tank?

Aquarium Co-Op points to a bigger tank: an angelfish’s body “is vertically oriented with a 6-inch (15 cm) length and 8-inch height. Therefore, a 29-gallon aquarium that is 18 inches (46 cm) tall would be more appropriate for angelfish.” Aqueon’s tank-size guide says angelfish “can be kept in small groups in tanks of this size range” in its 55-120 gallon section.

Q. How many 2-inch fish can go in a 20-gallon tank?

None of the sources here gives a count by length alone. Co-Op says the inch rule “mainly applies to small community fish that are approximately 1-3 inches (2-7 cm) in size”, and that zebra danios “are only 2 inches (5 cm) long but are very active and need more swimming room.”

Sources (17)
Aquarium Tales Team
Aquarium Tales Team

Written and reviewed by the Aquarium Tales Team. See the About page for how we work.