10 Fish for a Community Tank, and the Mixes Sources Warn Against

11 min read

The short answer

Makers and retailers name small, peaceful fish: neon tetras, harlequin rasboras, cherry barbs, zebra danios, guppies, platies and honey gouramis, with peppered corys, bristlenose plecos and kuhli loaches near the bottom. Buy schooling fish in groups, match water and temperature, and keep fin nippers and fish big enough to swallow tank mates out.

All ten are freshwater tropical fish; saltwater tanks, dwarf gouramis, mollies and otocinclus are not covered here. Figures come from LiveAquaria (LA), a live-fish retailer; Aqueon, an aquarium-products maker; API, a test-kit and water-care maker; Aquarian, a fish-food maker; and Aquarium Co-Op (Co-Op) and Buceplant, aquarium retailers. Sizes are LA’s “Maximum Size”. To research a fish not listed here, use our checklist for choosing fish; for a first tank, see our beginner fish guide.

The 10 at a Glance

FishSize; minimum tank (LA unless named)Group, by source
Neon tetra1.5 in; 10 gal6 or more (LA, Aqueon, Buceplant)
Harlequin rasbora2 in; 10 gal8-10 (LA); 7 or more (Aqueon)
Cherry barb2 in; LA: 20 gal (stats), “at least 30 gallons” (text); Aqueon: 10-20 gal6 to 10 (Aqueon, for barbs)
Zebra danio3 in; 10 gal6 or more (Aqueon); “small schools” (LA)
Guppy2 in; 10 gal2 to 3 females per male (Aqueon)
Platy2 in; 10 gal2 to 3 females per male (Aqueon)
Honey gourami2 in; 10 galMales “typically” kept alone; females “usually tolerate each other” (Aqueon)
Peppered cory2.5 in; 30 gal6 or more (LA); 5 or more (Aqueon, corys)
Bristlenose pleco6 in (LA), 4-5 in (Buceplant); 30 gal (LA), listed for 20-50 gal (Aqueon)Not given
Kuhli loachCo-Op: 3-4 in; 20 gal or larger3 to 6 (Co-Op); 5 or more (Aqueon)

General rules: Aqueon: “Always buy schooling fish in groups of 6 or more.” Aquarian: “A school of fish in an aquarium should always be at least 5 or more of the same species.”

Water and Temperature: LA vs Aqueon

Aqueon gives group ranges (for tetras, rasboras, barbs and gouramis, fish “raised commercially”); LA gives species ranges.

FishLA: pH; temperatureAqueon, for the group: pH; temperature
Neon tetra5.5-7.0; 68-78°FMost tetras: 6.8-7.8; 75-80°F
Harlequin rasbora6.0-6.5; 72-77°FRasboras: 6.8-7.8; 75-80°F (wild-caught pH 5.0-7.0)
Cherry barb6.0-7.0; 74-79°FBarbs: 6.8-7.8; 75-80°F
Zebra danio6.5-7.5; 64-75°FDanios: 7.0-7.8; 70-78°F
Guppy5.5-8.0; 64-82°FMost livebearers: 7.0-8.4; 74-78°F
Platy7.0-8.2; 64-77°FMost livebearers: 7.0-8.4; 74-78°F
Honey gourami6.0-8.0; 72-78°FGouramis: 6.8-7.8; 75-80°F
Peppered cory5.8-7.0; 72-79°FCaptive-bred corys: 7.0-8.0; 74-80°F
Bristlenose pleco6.5-7.4; 72-82°FMost captive-bred plecos: 7.0-8.0; 74-80°F
Kuhli loachCo-Op: “a wide range of pH”; 74-80°FLoaches: pH 6.0-8.0; “Temperature requirements vary depending on species”

API: “Most tropical species do well at 75°-78°F (24°-26°C).” Check the overlap before you mix: in LA’s figures, platies (64-77°F) and cherry barbs (74-79°F) share only 74-77°F (our comparison).

The Ten, One by One

Neon Tetra (Paracheirodon innesi)

LA: “Care Level: Easy”, “Temperament: Peaceful”, “Diet: Omnivore”. It says the fish “should be kept with similarly non-aggressive tankmates of a similar size.” API lists “Neon and Cardinal Tetras” for 10- to 20-gallon community tanks.

Harlequin Rasbora (Trigonostigma heteromorpha)

LA lists it as Rasbora heteromorpha; FishBase, a scientific fish database, uses Trigonostigma. LA rates it easy, peaceful and omnivorous, says a school fills “the upper areas of the aquarium”, and calls it “a great community fish”. Aquarian names harlequins among “excellent schooling fish for a community aquarium”.

Cherry Barb (Puntius titteya)

LA rates it easy, peaceful and omnivorous and calls it “a very timid fish that should be housed with fish of the same temperament.” Aqueon lists cherry barbs among the “peaceful species” that “make great community tank inhabitants”.

Zebra Danio (Danio rerio)

LA: easy, peaceful, omnivore, “a highly active swimmer”. Aqueon says danios are “active, to the point of being boisterous, but rarely cause injury to other fish.”

Guppy (Poecilia reticulata)

LA rates it easy and peaceful, says it “is an omnivore”, and says it “does well in freshwater community aquariums housing tankmates of similar temperament.”

Platy (Xiphophorus maculatus)

LA: easy, peaceful, omnivore; it “makes an excellent addition to the freshwater community aquarium.”

Honey Gourami (Trichogaster chuna)

LA: easy, peaceful, omnivore. It “must have access to the surface of the tank so it can breathe”, and its “ideal tank mates should be smaller, peaceful, and gentle.” It “does become territorial during spawning.” Aqueon: “Male gouramis have a tendency to be aggressive towards each other, so they should typically be kept individually. Female gouramis usually tolerate each other well.”

Peppered Cory (Corydoras paleatus)

LA: easy, peaceful, omnivore, “a peaceful bottom dwelling scavenger”. API lists peppered corys for 10- to 20-gallon tanks and Aquarian for “a 10 gallon tropical aquarium”; LA lists 30 gallons, and Aqueon says “A 30-gallon aquarium is best for most species”. Aqueon’s caution, in full: “Pristine water quality is essential to good health in these catfish. They should never be added to new aquariums or those that have been neglected.”

Bristlenose Pleco (Ancistrus sp.)

LA: easy, peaceful, omnivore; bristlenoses “make good additions to any community aquarium.” For 20-50 gallons, Aqueon calls it “A much better choice” than the common pleco and adds: “Like all bottom feeders, it should be fed specifically and not just dependent on algae and scraps.”

Kuhli Loach (Pangio kuhlii)

Co-Op calls kuhlis “a hardy, beginner-friendly fish” that can live “with other community fish like tetras, rasboras, and even betta fish.” Co-Op adds: “you must specifically feed them to make sure they don’t go hungry.” Aqueon suits them to tanks of “preferably 20 gallons or bigger”.

Tank-Mate Pairings Sources Name

FishTank mates namedSource
Tetras“other tetra species, rasboras, small danios, peaceful barbs, appropriately sized rainbowfish and livebearers”Aqueon
Livebearers“tetras, rasboras, danios, peaceful barbs and rainbowfish”Aqueon
Gouramis“Larger tetras, livebearers other than fancy guppies, peaceful barbs, most danios and angelfish”Aqueon
Guppies“tetras and corydoras catfish”Aqueon
Corys“most peaceful community fish”Aqueon
Kuhli loaches“tetras, rasboras, and even betta fish”Co-Op

For small tanks, see our guides to fish for a 10-gallon tank and fish for a 20-gallon tank.

Mixes Sources Warn Against

  • Fin nippers with slow or long-finned fish. Aqueon’s barb guide: “Some barbs communicate by nipping at each other, so avoid mixing these fish with timid, slow moving or long-finned fish such as neon tetras, angelfish, guppies or bettas.” It traces barbs’ fin-nipping name to “a few types like tiger barbs, rosy barbs and black ruby barbs”. LA rates the tiger barb “Semi-Aggressive”: it “may pester or even nip the fins of larger, slower moving fish.” Aqueon calls cherry barbs peaceful and names “peaceful barbs” for tetras, but pairs no species (our reading).
  • A fish that fits in another’s mouth. Aqueon cites “an old aquarium adage”: “if a fish can fit into another fish’s mouth, chances are it will end up there.” “Most fish are opportunistic when it comes to food, and even relatively peaceful fish will try to eat other fish if they think they can. Always purchase fish that are roughly the same size as those in your aquarium.” Of angelfish, which need “55 gallons or larger when full grown”, Aqueon says “they will not hesitate to eat smaller fish.”
  • Fish that outgrow the tank or the peace. Aqueon says the common pleco can grow to over 12 inches and “will eventually need an aquarium of at least 75 gallons”. Aquarian: “Some species are very peaceful when they are small but as they grow, they can become aggressive and solidary as adults.”
  • Rival males. API calls a single male betta “an ideal community aquarium resident” but says bettas “are intolerant of other males of their own kind.” Aqueon: “Male livebearers can be aggressive towards each other and are constantly trying to mate, so a ratio of 2 to 3 females per male is advised to prevent excessive harassment of the females.”
  • Cold-water fish with tropical fish. API: “tropical fish need warm water to survive and flourish,” while “Coldwater fish do not need to be kept in a heated aquarium.” Aqueon gives fancy goldfish an optimum of 68° to 74°F, below API’s 75-78°F for most tropical species (our comparison), and says: “If housed without a heater, they should be kept with other fish that are tolerant of cooler water temperatures.”

Before You Buy: Must-Haves

Answers to LA’s questions for every fish

Among them: “If the fish gets large, will it prey on or frighten smaller fish in the aquarium?” and “What kind of water does it require (pH, hardness, temperature, etc.)?”

Room for the adults

API: “It is important to know and understand the maximum adult size of the fish you are selecting.” Aqueon’s rule of thumb is “one inch of adult size fish per net gallon of aquarium capacity, but territorial fish need even more space”, and it warns that “a 30 gallon aquarium doesn’t actually hold 30 gallons of water when you factor in internal dimensions, gravel and decorations.” See our guides to fish for a 30-gallon tank and fish for a 55-gallon tank.

A slow start

API: “Adding a few fish at a time is a best practice. The fewer fish you add to the aquarium at a time allows the beneficial bacteria in the filter to catch up with the new fish load.” Aqueon: corys “should never be added to new aquariums”. See how to cycle a fish tank and how to add new fish.

A heater, set for the whole group

Aqueon advises a heater when the room is below 75° for tetras, rasboras and gouramis, 74° for livebearers, corys and plecos, and 70° for danios. See our tank temperature guide.

A secure lid

Aqueon’s guides for tetras, barbs, danios, livebearers and gouramis each say to keep one on.

Food that reaches the bottom

Aqueon: “Like all bottom feeders, it is important to feed them directly and not just depend on them getting leftovers from feeding other fish.” For kuhlis, Co-Op suggests feeding “at night when the lights are out” if other fish eat first.

A way to separate fish

Aqueon: “The best approach is to expect the unexpected and be prepared to separate fish that do not get along.”

Nice to Have

  • Fish for each level. Aquarian suggests choosing fish for “the topwater, midwater or bottom of the aquarium”. Aqueon says “Most danios are surface oriented” and “Most gouramis are surface oriented”, and calls livebearers “top to mid-water swimmers”; corys, bristlenoses and kuhlis feed on the bottom.
  • Plants and cover. Aqueon: “tall bushy plants provide habitat and give schooling fish like tetras, barbs, danios and rasboras their own areas to occupy,” and when fish “can’t see each other, they tend to mind their own business.”

What Changes the List

  • A larger tank. For tanks larger than 20 gallons, API adds swordtails, snakeskin gouramis, giant danios, rainbowfish, red-eyed tetras and scissortail rasboras.
  • Soft or hard water. LA’s platy pH range (7.0-8.2) misses harlequins (6.0-6.5) and meets neons (5.5-7.0) only at 7.0; Aqueon’s ranges for commercially raised rasboras (6.8-7.8) and most livebearers (7.0-8.4) do (our comparison).
  • Guppies with a gourami. Aqueon’s gourami guide names “livebearers other than fancy guppies” as tank mates.
  • Corys or loaches. LA says “A smooth sand or gravel substrate is needed because of the easily damaged barbels” for peppered corys; Aqueon calls sand or fine gravel “the best substrate for most loaches”.
  • Male and female livebearers. Aqueon: “if you have male and female livebearers, you will eventually have fry – plan accordingly!”

Ready to buy?

LA lists all nine of its species as omnivores; our tropical fish food roundup compares flakes, granules and pellets, and our Stocking section gathers the tank-size guides.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. What fish will keep my tank clean?

Aqueon says suckermouth catfish “are typically sold as algae eaters” but “some species are carnivorous” and others “feed almost exclusively on wood”, so research the diet first. See also our aquarium care tasks.

Q. What is the hardiest community fish?

No source here ranks one. Aqueon says “Danios are incredibly hardy and tolerate a wide range of temperature and water chemistry”, and that livebearers “tend to be peaceful, colorful and hardy”.

Q. Can goldfish live in a community tank?

Aqueon: “Goldfish get along well with most peaceful, similarly sized fish. Fin nippers and boisterous fish should be avoided.” It also says “Goldfish should never be kept in bowls, small aquariums or any unfiltered container!”

Q. Can a betta live in a community tank?

Aqueon: “Male bettas are highly territorial towards each other and must be kept separately or in a partitioned container. They can be kept with other fish in a peaceful community aquarium of 15 gallons or larger.” It also says to “Avoid putting them with male gouramis, fin-nippers such as tiger barbs or active fish like giant danios.” Our betta tank mates guide compares sources.

Q. What should I do if a new fish looks sick?

Test ammonia and nitrite, and contact an aquatic veterinarian about the fish; disease and medication are outside what this site covers.

Sources (31)
Aquarium Tales Team
Aquarium Tales Team

Written and reviewed by the Aquarium Tales Team. See the About page for how we work.