The short answer
No one type suits every tank. Aqueon, a filter maker, and LiveAquaria, a fish and supplies retailer, match the type to tank size and fish load: sponge filters for fry and small tanks, hang-on-back filters for most popular tank sizes, canisters for larger or busier tanks, internal filters for small tanks, undergravel for light loads and sumps for large setups.
LiveAquaria says to “base your decision on the size of your aquarium, as well as number of fish you hope to keep”. Aqueon’s checklist adds bioload, maintenance, flow rate, sound and water level.
What every filter is doing
Aqueon: “Aquarium filtration has three main components or stages: mechanical, chemical, and biological.”
- Mechanical “uses floss or foam materials to trap larger particles suspended in the water.”
- Biological “converts toxic ammonia from fish waste to nitrite (which is also toxic) and then converts the nitrite to nitrate.” Our guide to cycling a fish tank explains how those bacteria get established.
- Chemical “binds dissolved particles to a particular media to remove them from your aquarium water. It often uses activated carbon but might also use resins or clays.”
A second Aqueon page adds: “Many aquarium filters take care of all three stages but usually perform better in one or two.” On filter media, Aqueon says a filter “will always include the media you’re using to filter out particles, such as activated carbon or sand.”
Six filter types side by side
| Type | How water moves | Fit, per source |
|---|---|---|
| Sponge (air-driven) | Air bubbles pull water through foam | Fry, hospital, small tanks |
| Hang-on-back | Motor lifts water into a box on the rim | Most popular tank sizes |
| Canister | Pump pushes water through a sealed canister below | Larger or busier tanks |
| Internal power | Submerged pump inside the tank | Small tanks |
| Undergravel | Water pulled down through gravel on a plate | Light fish loads |
| Sump or wet/dry | Tank drains to a container below; pump returns it | Large setups |
Sponge filters
How it works. Aquarium Co-Op, an aquarium retailer that sells its own sponge filters: “The air pump pushes air through the airline tubing into the hollow cavity inside the sponge filter. Bubbles rise from the inside of the sponge, thus drawing water through the sponge walls.” It adds: “If the air pump is located below the top of the aquarium, you need to add a check valve to prevent water from flowing into the airline tubing whenever the air pump is turned off or the power is out.” Our sponge filter explainer covers the parts and the air pump safety lines.
Strengths. Co-Op calls them “cheap, easy to clean, and hard to break since they have very few mechanical parts”, and “gentle enough to avoid sucking up fish fry, shrimp, and other slow-moving creatures.”
Drawbacks. Aquariumscience.org, a single-author hobby reference site: “Sponge filters are ugly and obtrusive in the aquarium.” It adds that “air pumps can be VERY noisy”.
Fit. Aqueon: “Best for small tanks with fewer fish.” LiveAquaria puts air-driven internal filters in “rearing fry, hospital aquariums, and small aquariums with very small fish.” Ratings vary: AQQA, an aquarium equipment maker, says “The small filter is suitable for 5-20 gallon tanks, while the medium filter is suitable for 20-110 gallon tanks.”
Hang-on-back (power) filters
How it works. LiveAquaria: “They are designed to hang off the back of your aquarium”. Fluval’s AquaClear manual says the filter “draws water from the aquarium through an extension tube into the motor”, and the intake “directs the flow of unfiltered water through filter inserts to trap particles, debris, and purify the water.”
Strengths. LiveAquaria calls power filters “very easy to use” and says “Replaceable filter cartridges make maintenance simple and convenient.”
Drawbacks. Some, such as the AquaClear, need priming. Its manual’s start-up step is “Allow 30-45 seconds for priming”, with the warning “DO NOT OPERATE FILTER WITHOUT WATER”.
Fit. LiveAquaria: “the perfect filter for most popular aquarium sizes housing a variety of tropical fishes.” Two makers’ rated tank size and flow, from our roundups: the Tidal 35 is “rated by Seachem for up to 35 gallons” at “130 US GPH”, and “Fluval rates the AquaClear 50 for 20 to 50 gallons at a maximum 200 GPH”.
Canister filters
How it works. Aqueon: “This uses a water pump to force water through different types of substances that create mechanical, biological, and chemical filtration.” Fluval’s 06 Series manual calls its canister “a gravity-fed system” and says “The filter must ALWAYS be positioned below the aquarium.”
Strengths. LiveAquaria: “Canister filters provide superior mechanical, chemical, and biological filtration for larger aquariums or aquariums with a lot of fish.” It calls them “ideal for African and South American Cichlid aquariums, saltwater aquariums, as well as freshwater planted aquariums.”
Drawbacks. LiveAquaria: “Compared to power filters, canister filters require slightly more effort to set up and maintain.” Aqueon: “Needs frequent cleaning but is great for larger aquariums.” Fluval’s manual warns: “The rubber seal will perish over time and will lead to leaking of canister if not replaced.”
Fit. Larger or heavily stocked tanks, per LiveAquaria. Our canister filter roundup compares models by tank size, and our Fluval, Aqueon and Eheim comparison compares three canister lines.
Internal power filters
How it works. LiveAquaria: “Imagine a power filter you can completely place underwater.”
Strengths. Aqueon: “If you want to maintain a lower water level in the aquarium, an internal filter that suctions to the side will sit lower and be quieter than a hang-on back filter that sits or hangs from the top rim.”
Fit. The sources give different ceilings. LiveAquaria: “They are made for smaller aquariums, generally under 20-gallons.” Aqueon sells its QuietFlow internal filter in three sizes up to “Medium (15-30G)”, and rates the smallest at “0-35GPH” with “Adjustable flow rates for 0-5G fresh or saltwater aquarium.”
Undergravel filters
How it works. Aqueon: “This uses an air pump to pull water through a slotted plate under your aquarium’s substrate, then circulates the water to the top of your tank.” LiveAquaria says they “rely on either an air pump or powerhead to function” and are “primarily biological filters.” Aquariumscience.org: “The thickness of the gravel should be one to two inches”.
Strengths. LiveAquaria: “relatively inexpensive”. Aquariumscience.org: “Air operated under gravels have no moving parts that need replacing.”
Drawbacks, and a disagreement. Gravel matters: Aquariumscience.org says an undergravel filter “does best with 3/16ths aquarium gravel”, and that sand and other substrates have “large downsides”. On cleaning, the sources conflict. Aqueon: “If you’re using an under-gravel filter for biological filtration, you need to vacuum the substrate in your aquarium frequently.” Aquariumscience.org: “If under gravels are frequently cleaned (and the term “cleaned” includes “deep vacuuming”) they do not work.”
Fit. LiveAquaria: “These filters are available for small or large aquariums but are best suited for aquariums with a light fish load.” Aqueon: “Best for tanks not densely packed with fish.” The single-author Aquariumscience.org, which favors them, disagrees: left alone, it says, they are “a great, inexpensive filter with a huge bioload capacity.”
Sumps and wet/dry filters
How it works. Bulk Reef Supply, a reef aquarium retailer, writing for saltwater keepers: “A sump is a container of water that sits below your display aquarium that is used to house your filtration and additional life support equipment”. Then: “Water drains from the display aquarium down into the sump via a drain in the display. That water passes through the sump filtration and is then pumped back up into the aquarium via the return pump.” LiveAquaria says most wet/dry filters “include a sump/reservoir”, and that the name comes from biological media “exposed to both aquarium water (wet) and a significant amount of air (dry).”
Strengths. Bulk Reef Supply: “You also increase the system’s total water volume which ultimately helps improve stability.” LiveAquaria: “Wet/dry filters provide the ultimate in biological filtration.”
Drawbacks. LiveAquaria: “In general, these aquarium filters require the most effort to set up since they need to be installed or plumbed to the aquarium in a rather elaborate manner.” Single-author Aquariumscience.org: “The design of the system needs about six different safety features to prevent overflows.” It adds: “Purchased sumps are very expensive and designed for saltwater tanks, so they need modifications for freshwater.”
Fit. Bulk Reef Supply: “For reef aquariums, most would agree as a sump is better than a canister filter for a few reasons.” LiveAquaria: “great for saltwater fish-only aquariums or any large aquarium setup that demands efficient biological filtration.” For sizing, Bulk Reef Supply’s saltwater guide says: “The general rule is no less than 25% of your tank’s total water volume for the best results.”
Reading flow ratings
Aqueon gives the most-cited flow rule on two pages, in two wordings: “Ideally, the flow rate of your filter should be between four and six times the size of your tank.” and “A hardworking filter should have a flow rate at least four times the volume of the tank per hour to keep the water clean.”
Check which figure a maker prints. Fluval’s 06 Series manual gives two for each canister. For the 106, rated for 25 US gallons, it lists 145 US gallons an hour of pump output and 95 of filter circulation. On a 25-gallon tank, 95 GPH is about 3.8 turnovers an hour, under Aqueon’s four, and 145 GPH about 5.8 (our arithmetic). Modest Fish, timing new canisters, found the flow “much lower than the rating listed on the box” for every canister it tested, as our roundup reports.
Flow gentleness matters too. Aqueon: “Fish with more delicate fins, like betta, will need a more gentle flow than a fish like a danio.” Our guide to reducing filter current covers ways to turn it down.
Matching a type to your tank
| Your tank | Types the sources point to | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Fry, shrimp or hospital tank | Sponge (air-driven) | LiveAquaria, Aquarium Co-Op |
| Small tank, few fish | Sponge or internal | Aqueon, LiveAquaria |
| Popular sizes, tropical community | Hang-on-back | LiveAquaria |
| Large or heavily stocked | Canister or sump | LiveAquaria, Aqueon |
| Cichlid, planted or saltwater | Canister | LiveAquaria |
| Reef or saltwater fish-only | Sump or wet/dry | Bulk Reef Supply, LiveAquaria |
| Light load on gravel | Undergravel | LiveAquaria, Aqueon |
Aqueon: “Filters are often combined for greater filtration and efficiency. For example, you might use a sponge filter alongside an external power filter.” One pick each for three of these types, from our sponge, hang-on-back and fish tank filters roundups:
| # | Preview | Product | Price | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ![]() | hygger Aquarium Sponge Filter 20-55 Gallon Fish Tank Filter…Air-driven sponge filter | $15.99 | Check on Amazon |
| 2 | ![]() | Seachem Tidal Filter, 35 gal. (135 L) NA 120 V, 60 Hz, US…Self-priming hang-on-back | Check on Amazon | |
| 3 | ![]() | Fluval 307 Performance Canister Filter for Aquariums Up to…Mid-size canister | $217.99 Prime | Check on Amazon |
Ready to buy?
Our fish tank filters roundup compares picks by tank size, with deeper sponge and canister roundups and more in our Filters & Media section.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q. Which is better, a sponge filter or a hang-on-back?
LiveAquaria’s comparison table rates air-driven internal filters “Low” for mechanical and chemical filtration and “Medium” for biological, and power filters “Medium” on all three. It rates both “Basic” to set up.
Q. What type of aquarium filter is most effective?
In the same table, only wet/dry filters rate “High” for biological filtration; canisters rate “High” for mechanical and chemical. Wet/dry filters are also the only type it rates “Advanced” to set up.
Q. Is a Fluval or Aqueon filter better?
Our Fluval, Aqueon and Eheim comparison sets each line’s published ratings, media and warranty side by side.
Sources (12)
- Aqueon (maker), Aquarium Filtration Basics
- Aqueon (maker), How to Choose the Best Filter for You and Your Tank
- Aqueon (maker), QuietFlow Internal Power Filters with SmartClean Technology
- LiveAquaria (retailer), Aquarium Filter Selection Guide
- Aquarium Co-Op (retailer), Sponge Filters: The Easiest Fish Tank Filter Ever
- AQQA (maker), aquarium sponge filter for 5-20 gallon tanks
- Fluval (maker), AquaClear 20-110 power filter manual (Amazon-hosted copy)
- Fluval (maker), 06 Series canister filter manual (Amazon-hosted copy)
- Bulk Reef Supply (retailer), Saltwater Aquarium Sumps & HOW They Work!
- Aquariumscience.org (single-author hobby reference site), 8.4. Sponge Filters
- Aquariumscience.org, 8.5. Under-Gravel Filters
- Aquariumscience.org, 8.6. Sump Filters
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.



