The short answer
For a slow-sinking pellet that Fluval’s Amazon listing says contains “up to 40%” black soldier fly larvae, Fluval Bug Bites Goldfish Pellets; for a low-cost granule that Aqueon says sinks to the bottom, Aqueon Goldfish Granules; for a flake Tetra sells as a staple for goldfish, Tetra Goldfish Flakes.
Our verdict
Our Top Picks at a Glance
Seven goldfish foods, from sinking pellets to flakes, crisps and sticks, compared on maker pages, Amazon listings and owner reports; we have not tested them. All are sold by Amazon.com; Saki-Hikari, Repashy Super Gold, Omega One and Northfin, often named in goldfish sources, did not pass that seller check.
Goldfish food finder
Find a goldfish food
Pick a food type and a pack-price tier; packs run from 2.46 to 7.12 oz, so compare sizes too. The suggestion is our editorial starting point, drawn from the seven foods below, not a test result.
Compare the picks
Compare the 7 goldfish foods
“Form”: the maker’s wording for the linked pack, shortened.
Fluval Goldfish PelletsInsect-first sinking pelletMedium-large goldfish, larvae listed first, sinkingSlow-sinking pellets$7.90 Prime
Evidence: specs from Fluval's Amazon listing; one owner lists 'Fluval Bugbite' among good dry foods (formula and size not stated)
Aqueon GranulesBudget sinking granuleFancy goldfish, common goldfish, sinkingSinking granules$6.19 Prime
Evidence: maker specs; no independent test found
Tetra Goldfish FlakesStaple flakeGoldfish, small koi, stapleFlakes$9.97 Prime
Evidence: maker specs; no independent test found
API Goldfish PelletsSinking pellet, large packGoldfish, sinkingSinking pellets$11.98 Prime
Evidence: maker specs; no independent test found
Aqueon Goldfish FlakesFloating flakeSurface feeders, natural colorsFloating flakes$14.49 Prime
Evidence: maker specs; no independent test found
TetraPro CrispsFloating crispSurface feeders, longer floatingFloating crisps$7.50 Prime
Evidence: maker specs; no independent test found
Tetra Worm BitesWorm-shaped sticksSurface feeders, easy portionsFloating sticks$6.27 Prime
Evidence: maker specs; no independent test found
Sinking or Floating? What Goldfish Keepers Should Know Before Buying
Sinking or floating. The sources disagree. Dr. Jessie Sanders, a board-certified fish veterinarian, writes in The Spruce Pets that pellets beat flakes because “goldfish that eat food at the surface may ingest air, and round bodied goldfish such as orandas may develop floating disorders”; flakes, she suggests, can be released under the surface. The fishkeeping awareness site INJAF says “Sinking food is preferable for fancy goldfish” and that singletail goldfish are “usually quite happy munching on floating food as well as sinking”. Aquarium Co-Op, a store that sells fish and food, takes the other side: “we regularly feed floating foods and have not seen any health issues with our fish.” INJAF’s singletail exception is its own view; Dr. Sanders recommends pellets for goldfish without that split.
Per the makers, the Fluval pellets are “slow sinking”, the API pellets and Aqueon granules sink, and the Aqueon flakes, TetraPro crisps and Tetra sticks float. INJAF suggests soaking dry food “for a minute or two” before feeding, but “not too long” because nutrients may leach out into the water.
Protein, fat and fiber. Dr. Sanders gives a maintenance protein level “around 30%” for goldfish and “around 35%” for juveniles and breeding fish, and says fat above “5-8%” is “not necessary for adult goldfish”. She adds that high fiber “is of no benefit to your fish”. None of the seven publishes a crude-protein or fiber figure in the text we could read (some maker pages show label images we could not read); check the tub’s guaranteed analysis.
First ingredients (Amazon listings): black soldier fly larvae for Fluval; fish meal for the Tetra flakes, TetraPro and both Aqueon foods; whole menhaden fish meal for API; none in the text we read for the Tetra sticks. More on these in what fish food is made of.
Food is not a treatment: if a goldfish floats oddly, stops eating or looks unwell, test the water (our freshwater test kit roundup compares kits; our guide to why goldfish die in aquariums covers water causes) and contact an aquatic veterinarian.
How We Chose These Goldfish Foods
How this guide was built
built from manufacturer documentation, published guides and owner reports; we have not tested these products ourselves.
What we compared, in order
Species fit (made or labeled for goldfish); food form, sinking or floating and size as the maker states; first ingredients; a maker feeding direction; pack size and price. All seven were sold by Amazon.com on the live product page when checked. Price tiers in the reviews: $ = lowest, $$ = middle, $$$ = highest pack price here; packs run from 2.46 to 7.12 oz, so compare sizes too.
Sources and how we graded them and what goldfish owners say
Sources and how we graded them
We found no independent test of any pick. Product facts come from the makers’ pages and Amazon listings (Fluval’s site showed a bot check, so its facts come from its listing). Aquarium Co-Op is quoted as a retailer’s opinion.
What goldfish owners say
In a ranking r/Goldfish thread, one owner wrote “Sinking pellets r the best imo”; another had fed floating pellets “for over 10 years to hundreds of fish” without a swim-bladder problem they tied to food. Three replies criticized Tetra as a brand, not a named Tetra food. Repashy gel got some of the warmest praise; it did not pass our seller check.
Detailed Reviews: The 7 Goldfish Foods
Fluval Bug Bites Goldfish Pellets, Insect-first sinking pellet
3.53 oz · Slow-sinking pellets
Keepers of medium to large goldfish who want a slow-sinking pellet with black soldier fly larvae listed first.
$7.90 from AmazonAs of Nov 19, 00:48 UTCVerdict
Slow-sinking 5-7 mm pellets that Fluval’s Amazon listing says contain “up to 40%” black soldier fly larvae, the first ingredient.
Evidence: No independent test; owner reports. r/Goldfish: Bug Bites, formula and size not stated.
The listing aims the pellets at “Medium to Large Sized Fish”; corn, corn gluten meal and wheat follow the larvae. Fluval also sells Bug Bites Goldfish as 1.4-1.6 mm granules for small to medium fish. In the r/Goldfish thread above, one owner listed “Fluval Bugbite” among good dry foods (formula and size not stated).
Specs (linked: 3.53 oz)
- First ingredients: dried black soldier fly larvae, corn, corn gluten meal
Pros
- Insect larvae listed as the first ingredient, in a pellet that sinks slowly
Cons
- The listing sizes the 5-7 mm pellets for medium to large fish
- Fluval’s own site could not be read, so facts rest on its listing
Who should buy it
Keepers of medium to large goldfish who want a slow-sinking pellet with black soldier fly larvae listed first.
Aqueon Goldfish Granules, Budget sinking granule
Keepers of fancy or common goldfish who want a low-cost food that sinks.
$6.19 from AmazonAs of Nov 19, 00:48 UTCVerdict
Granules of about 1.5 mm that Aqueon says “sink to the bottom of the aquarium”.
Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Aqueon Goldfish Granules page.
Aqueon calls them “Good for common goldfish, fancy Orandas or small koi” and lists varieties from Fantails to Ryukins, Lionheads and Moors. It says they will not cloud water “when fed as directed”.
Specs (linked: 5.8 oz)
- First ingredients: fish meal, wheat, dehulled soybean meal (listing)
Pros
- Small sinking granules, with fancy varieties named by Aqueon
Cons
- The listing’s direction gives a time limit but no number of meals a day
Who should buy it
Keepers of fancy or common goldfish who want a low-cost food that sinks.
Tetra Goldfish Flakes, Staple flake
Keepers of goldfish or small koi who want the flake Tetra calls its best selling goldfish food.
$9.97 from AmazonAs of Nov 19, 00:48 UTCVerdict
Flakes Tetra’s listing calls “a staple flake food for your goldfish or small koi”.
Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Tetra GoldFish Flakes page.
Tetra says the flakes “do not leach color”, keeping water clear. The listing names artificial colors (Yellow 5, Red 3, Blue 2) and ethoxyquin as a preservative.
Specs (linked: 7.06 oz)
- First ingredients: fish meal, ground brown rice, torula dried yeast (listing)
Pros
- Fish meal listed first, in a flake Tetra makes for goldfish
Cons
- A flake, the form Dr. Sanders ranks below pellets
- Artificial colors and ethoxyquin in the ingredient list
Who should buy it
Keepers of goldfish or small koi who want the flake Tetra calls its best selling goldfish food.
API Goldfish Pellets, Sinking pellet, large pack
Keepers of goldfish who want a sinking pellet in a 7 oz tub.
$11.98 from AmazonAs of Nov 19, 00:48 UTCVerdict
Sinking pellets API calls “ideal for all types of Goldfish including Shubunkins, Lionheads and Fantails”.
Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: API Goldfish Pellets page.
API claims its food produces “up to 30% less ammonia” (comparison not stated). It names no pellet size and publishes no fiber figure in the text we read.
Specs (linked: 7 oz)
- First ingredients: whole menhaden fish meal, whole wheat, squid meal (listing)
Pros
- A sinking pellet API names for Shubunkins, Lionheads and Fantails
Cons
- No pellet size published in the text we read
Aqueon Goldfish Flakes, Floating flake
Keepers who feed flakes, accept INJAF's caution for fancy goldfish and want a flake Aqueon says uses natural colors.
$14.49 from AmazonAs of Nov 19, 00:48 UTCVerdict
“Flakes that float at the surface”, which Aqueon makes with “Natural ingredients and colors”.
Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Aqueon Goldfish Flakes page.
The listing names the same fancy varieties as #2, lists spirulina, kelp, spinach and chlorella further down, and gives astaxanthin and tagetes (marigold) extract as its colors.
Specs (linked: 7.12 oz)
- First ingredients: whole fish meal, wheat flour, dehulled soybean meal (listing)
Pros
- Natural colors, per Aqueon, with greens on the ingredient list
Cons
- Floats, which INJAF advises against for fancy goldfish
- The highest pack price here
Who should buy it
Keepers who feed flakes, accept INJAF’s caution for fancy goldfish and want a flake Aqueon says uses natural colors.
TetraPro Goldfish Crisps, Floating crisp
Keepers who want a floating crisp rather than a flake and accept INJAF's caution for fancy goldfish.
$7.50 from AmazonAs of Nov 19, 00:48 UTCVerdict
Crisps Tetra says “float longer to allow fish more time to eat” and feed “cleaner than ordinary flakes”.
Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: TetraPro Goldfish Crisps page.
Tetra says a low-heat process “preserves essential vitamins”. The listing names artificial colors among the ingredients.
Specs (linked: 3.03 oz)
- First ingredients: fish meal, ground brown rice, dried yeast (listing)
Pros
- Crisps that float longer than flakes, per Tetra
Cons
- Floats by design, the opposite of what INJAF advises for fancy goldfish
Who should buy it
Keepers who want a floating crisp rather than a flake and accept INJAF’s caution for fancy goldfish.
Tetra Goldfish Worm Shaped Bites, Worm-shaped sticks
Verdict
Floating food sticks Tetra calls “a nutritionally complete diet for all varieties of goldfish”.
Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Tetra Goldfish Worm Shaped Bites page.
Tetra says “The shape of the stick allows easy portioning.” The Amazon listing gives no ingredient list (“See label”); Tetra’s page shows a label image we could not read.
Specs (linked: 2.46 oz)
- First ingredients: not in the text we read
Pros
- Stick shape for easy portioning, per Tetra
Cons
- No ingredient list in the text we read
- The smallest pack here
How Much and How Often to Feed Goldfish
Follow the label of the food you buy; the makers’ directions differ (Amazon listings; API’s and Tetra’s own pages for #4 and #7):
| Food | Meals a day | How much (quoted) |
|---|---|---|
| Fluval (#1) | Two to three | “as much as your fish can eat in two minutes” |
| Aqueon (#2, #5) | Not stated | “no more than what the fish can eat within 1 – 2 minutes” |
| Tetra flakes (#3) | Two to three | “only as much as your fish can consume within several minutes” |
| API (#4) | Twice | “only as much as fish will consume within 3 minutes” |
| TetraPro, Tetra sticks (#6, #7) | Two to three | “only as much as your fish can consume within three minutes” |
API’s Amazon listing words it as “up to twice a day”.
Other sources differ too. Dr. Sanders ties meals to water temperature: in the lower 70s °F and below (under 23 °C), “feed your goldfish once per day”; above that, twice. SRAC 7201, an aquaculture fact sheet on goldfish and koi raised for sale, notes that goldfish “lack true stomachs, so they benefit from multiple feedings each day”. Follow the label and Dr. Sanders’ temperature rule. Uneaten food fouls water; if it turns hazy, see why aquarium water turns cloudy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q. Are flakes or pellets better for goldfish?
Dr. Sanders prefers pellets (see above), noting that in stored food vitamin C declines faster in flakes than in pellets; Aquarium Co-Op feeds floating food without problems.
Q. Should goldfish be fed every day?
API says twice a day, Fluval and Tetra two or three times; Aqueon gives only a time limit. Dr. Sanders suggests once a day in cooler water, twice in warmer. For gaps between meals, see how long fish can go without food.
Q. What can I feed goldfish when I’m out of fish food?
In general guidance for most aquarium fish, not goldfish alone, Aqueon says they “are fine not being fed for three to seven days”, so skipping a meal or two is an option. For plant foods it lists “sliced zucchini, cucumber, romaine lettuce, sweet potato, peas, and spinach”, clipped to the glass and “removed after 24 hours”, and it counts goldfish among the omnivores that like those foods. It says never to feed bread, crackers or “vegetables with seasoning, dressing, or sauces”. If a goldfish refuses food or looks unwell, test the water and contact an aquatic veterinarian.
Q. Can goldfish and koi eat the same food?
Some foods are labeled for both: Aqueon says its granules are “Good for common goldfish, fancy Orandas or small koi”, and Tetra makes its goldfish flakes for “goldfish or small koi”.
The bottom line
Final Verdict
Start with Fluval Bug Bites Goldfish Pellets (check price) for a slow-sinking pellet with insect larvae listed first, Aqueon Goldfish Granules (check price) for a low-cost food that sinks or Tetra Goldfish Flakes (check price) for a staple flake; the table above covers the other four.
More guides: keeping tropical fish or bettas too? See our tropical fish food and betta food guides, or browse all food and feeding guides.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
